Sourdough French Toast: Easy Recipe for the Best Breakfast Ever

Sourdough French Toast is my not-so-secret breakfast weapon. You know those lazy mornings when everyone’s kinda grumpy and there’s nothing exciting in the fridge? This totally fixes that. It’s easy, tastes like a five-star brunch, and uses up yesterday’s sourdough without a single complaint from my picky cousin (miracles happen). I actually grabbed most of the recipe from my go-to page on How to Make the Best Sourdough Banana Muffins

What Is Sourdough French Toast and Why It’s So Popular

Alright, so Sourdough French Toast sounds a bit weird at first, I get it. It’s classic French toast’s quirky cousin, uses tangy sourdough bread instead of softer white stuff. What’s the big deal? Honestly, everything. That chewy, slightly sour slice soaks up egg like a sponge (but not in a gross way). It doesn’t get soggy, either stays crisp outside, custardy inside. People are excited about it because you get that flavor punch regular bread just can’t give. I once served it at a brunch party and folks still bring it up at family reunions. Nobody remembers boring French toast, but they remember this.

Print

Key Ingredients for the Best Sourdough French Toast

Let’s keep it simple. Here’s what you actually need to nail Sourdough French Toast: thick slices of sourdough bread (can’t cheat with thin supermarket stuff), eggs (three is good, but I’ve used four if I was feeling wild), milk (any kind, but whole milk is king for richness), a pinch of salt and cinnamon (so basic don’t skip), and a splash of vanilla if you’re feeling fancy. Oh, real butter for the pan. That’s it, no complicated ingredients. The best part? If your sourdough is a day or two old, it works even better. Don’t overthink it.

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Sourdough French Toast

Okay, pull up a chair. Here’s how you actually make Sourdough French Toast at home, with zero drama. Crack your eggs in a big bowl, whisk like your life depends on it. Toss in your milk, salt, cinnamon, and that vanilla. Dunk your bread, but don’t leave it drowning! Flip each slice, give it just enough time to drink up the custard (about 20 seconds per side usually does the trick). Drop some butter in a hot pan, wait till it sizzles. Lay down your soaked bread, cook until golden and crisp, then flip. That smell? It’s magic. Finish every batch fresh, nobody likes cold French toast. Keep ‘em warm in the oven if you must, but they’re best hot-off-the-pan.

Tips for Success and Mistakes to Avoid

Wanna know the secret to avoiding soggy disasters? For real, keep your bread thick and let it go stale a bit. If your slices are too fresh, they fall apart… drama you don’t need. Don’t skimp on whisking your custard, or you’ll end up with weird eggy bites. Hot pan is a must, or you’ll get pale sad toast. Last tip: don’t cram the pan so everyone has elbow room to get crispy. A tiny mess is okay, trust me. Every time I rushed or crammed, I regretted it. Oh, and always taste a test slice, my grandma’s rule.

Best Types of Sourdough Bread for French Toast

So maybe you’re wondering: Which kind of sourdough bread actually works for French toast? Thick, rustic bakery-style loaves are my top pick. The slices take on the custard and still hold up no floppy mess. I once tried a regular supermarket sourdough and, yikes, it melted like snow in July. Crusty, hearty loaves with real texture are the gold standard. Seeded loaves? Maybe not. They’re weirdly distracting. And homemade unbeatable. Check out how to make sourdough garlic bread if you want to get adventurous with homemade loaves in general, which totally levels up any French toast.

Delicious Variations of Sourdough French Toast

Let’s get creative for a hot minute. You can mix in orange zest and a splash of orange juice for a citrusy punch. Sprinkle a handful of chocolate chips onto your bread just before tossing it in the pan. Want it savory? Ditch the cinnamon and vanilla, add cheddar and chives, and swap syrup for hot sauce (sounds weird but wow). Once I made a pumpkin spice version in October and people lost their minds. No rules here, just whatever makes you happy that morning.

Serving Suggestions and Topping Ideas

Here’s where you can take your Sourdough French Toast totally over the top with basically zero effort:

• Real maple syrup, don’t mess with fake stuff.
• Fresh berries or banana slices, always a crowd pleaser.
• Dust with powdered sugar for that coffee shop vibe.
• A dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream, if you’re feeling wild.

Best Drinks to Serve (Coffee, Tea, Smoothies)

Pairing your Sourdough French Toast? Obvious first choice is coffee, the smell of it with hot French toast is honestly life-changing. Fancy teas work if you want to be classy, especially chai or Earl Grey. Fruity smoothies make it a “healthy brunch” (kinda). I once served cold brew with maple syrup, and wow, try it at least once. Mimosas work too if you’re in brunch mode; just saying.

Side Dishes That Balance Sweet and Savory

Balance is key. Crispy bacon or sausage and scrambled eggs are my faves next to Sourdough French Toast, especially when you want that sweet and salty contrast. Hashbrowns work too (yeah, carbs on carbs, but who cares at brunch). Sometimes, I’ll slice up some oranges or throw together a quick fruit salad if I wanna pretend I’m doing something healthy. No one ever complains.

Troubleshooting Guide for Sourdough French Toast

If your French toast comes out chewy or like rubber? Probably too much custard or not enough soaking. Too dry? Bread was either too thick or pan was too hot. If it’s undercooked inside, just lower the heat and let it chill for another minute. Got stuck on the pan? Not enough butter. Sometimes the first slice flops and you think you’ve failed, nope, just adjust and keep going.

“I’d never tried making French toast with sourdough until I saw it here. Seriously, the texture blew my mind! Easy recipe, totally restaurant-worthy results my kids actually asked for seconds.” Tina D.

Storage, Freezing, and Reheating Instructions

Sourdough French Toast stores like a champ, if you ever have leftovers (rare in my house). Toss cooled slices in a resealable bag, fridge for up to three days. For the freezer, layer parchment between slices and freeze; pop them straight in the toaster oven when hunger strikes. They’re honestly not bad microwaved, but the texture is best from a hot pan or oven.

Sourdough vs. Regular Bread for French Toast

Here’s my strong take: Sourdough French Toast is just better. Regular bread gets mushy and bland, but sourdough keeps things sturdy, tangy, and so much more interesting. That contrast of crispy crust and soft middle? Heaven. I know some folks are loyal to brioche, but for me, nothing beats sourdough for French toast. It makes breakfast feel special, not boring.

Sourdough French Toast for Special Diets and Occasions

If someone in your house eats dairy-free or gluten-free, use a plant milk (almond or oat is pretty good) and opt for a gluten-free sourdough if you can find it. I’ve even made it with oat milk and flaxseed “eggs” for vegan friends, they didn’t hate it! Sourdough French Toast is perfect for birthday brunches, holidays, or pretty much any time you want people to rave about your cooking skills, no special event required.

KitchenAid Mixer and Bread Pans for Homemade Loaves

If you’ve got a KitchenAid mixer, making your own sourdough bread for French toast is weirdly satisfying (and easier than you’d think). Same for loaf pans, go heavy and sturdy so your bread bakes up tall and proud. There’s a certain bragging right in serving Sourdough French Toast made with bread you actually baked yourself. I mean, who doesn’t want to impress their in-laws or Sunday guests?

Ingredient	Quantity	Notes
Sourdough Bread	4 slices (1 inch thick)	Stale bread works best for texture
Eggs	3 large	Use fresh eggs for best results
Milk	1/2 cup	Whole milk is preferred for creaminess
Salt	Pinch	Enhances overall flavor
Cinnamon	1/2 tsp	Optional but adds warmth to flavor
Vanilla Extract	1 tsp	For extra flavor depth
Butter	1-2 tbsp	For frying

Common Questions

Why You’ll Want to Try Sourdough French Toast Now

Life’s honestly too short for boring breakfasts. Sourdough French Toast brings flavor, texture, and a little bit of “you made WHAT?!” energy to your morning. You’ll use up that old bread, impress literally anyone (even the in-laws), and find yourself craving it on Mondays. If you want more easy baking ideas, don’t miss these tasty sourdough hamburger buns next time. Try it out and see why it nearly always beats regular French toast, no contest.