Delicious Surf and Turf with Creamy Garlic Sauce Recipe

Surf and Turf with Creamy Garlic Sauce is my shortcut to fancy date-night vibes at home. I get it, you want impressive restaurant flavor without babysitting three pans or stressing about timing. With a few smart tricks, you can pull off tender steak, juicy shrimp, and a silky garlic sauce that brings it all together. This Delicious Surf and Turf with Creamy Garlic Sauce Recipe is my go-to when I want something special but still practical for a weeknight. You can keep it classic with steak and shrimp, or switch in lobster tails if you’re feeling extra. Let’s make this meal feel big without feeling complicated.

Essential Ingredients: Choosing the Best Steak and Seafood

Steak picks

For this Delicious Surf and Turf with Creamy Garlic Sauce Recipe, quality matters. You want a well-marbled steak for flavor and tenderness. My top pick is ribeye for that buttery bite, followed by a thick-cut New York strip. If you love a super tender cut, filet mignon is dreamy too. Choose steaks at least 1 to 1.5 inches thick for a good sear and a juicy center.

Seafood picks

Jumbo shrimp are quick, meaty, and soak up garlic butter like a pro. Just make sure they’re peeled and deveined. If you want to go fancy, lobster tails are fantastic. Keep it simple: high-quality seafood plus a hot pan equals magic.

• Steak: 2 ribeye or NY strip steaks, 1 to 1.5 inches thick
• Shrimp: 12 to 16 jumbo shrimp, peeled and deveined
• Seasoning: Kosher salt, black pepper, smoked paprika, garlic powder
• Fats: Butter and olive oil
• For the sauce: Garlic, heavy cream, Parmesan, lemon, and parsley

Need ideas for what to serve alongside? I’ve got a whole section on sides below, but you can also browse more appetizer and side ideas for inspiration.

Pro Tips for the Best Cut: Filet Mignon vs. Ribeye vs. NY Strip

Ribeye is rich and flavorful thanks to fat marbling. It’s forgiving and stays juicy even if you overshoot your target temp a bit. If you prefer straight-up tenderness, filet mignon is your pick. It’s lean, so baste generously with butter to add flavor. New York strip sits in the middle: a bit leaner than ribeye with a satisfying chew and a bold beefy taste.

Whichever cut you pick, pat it dry, season well, and let it sit at room temp for about 30 minutes before cooking. This helps the steak cook more evenly and sear beautifully. A dry surface equals a better crust. That crust is where so much flavor lives.

How to Select and Prep Jumbo Shrimp (or Lobster Tails)

For shrimp, look for plump, firm pieces with a fresh ocean smell. If they smell strong or feel slimy, skip them. I buy them peeled and deveined to save time. Pat them dry and season with salt, pepper, and a pinch of paprika. Dry shrimp sear better, just like steak.

For lobster tails, use kitchen shears to cut the top of the shell down the center and gently lift the meat on top of the shell. Brush with butter, sprinkle salt and pepper, and bake or pan-sear. Lobster loves garlic butter, which makes it perfect for this dish.

Quick note: shrimp cook fast. Plan to make them right after the steak rests so everything lands on the table hot.

The Secret to a Perfect Creamy Garlic Butter Sauce

What makes it silky

The sauce is simple but powerful. Melt butter, gently sauté finely minced garlic until fragrant, then add heavy cream. Let it simmer on low so it thickens without breaking. Stir in grated Parmesan, a squeeze of lemon for brightness, and black pepper. A little pasta water or stock can thin it if needed. Aim for smooth, glossy, and pourable.

What to avoid

Don’t boil the cream hard or you’ll risk curdling. Keep the heat low and whisk as the cheese melts. If you love creamy garlic flavors, you might also enjoy this creamy garlic parmesan chicken breast on another night. Same idea, different star of the plate.

Flavor boosters: A tiny splash of white wine (reduce before adding cream), fresh parsley, and a pinch of crushed red pepper for heat.

Step-by-Step Instructions: Cooking the Perfect Surf and Turf

Quick timeline

Follow this flow and your timing will be on point. It’s the easiest way to nail this Delicious Surf and Turf with Creamy Garlic Sauce Recipe without stress.

• Season steaks and let them sit at room temp. Pat dry right before cooking.
• Heat a heavy skillet until very hot. Add oil, then steak. Don’t crowd the pan.
• Sear 2 to 3 minutes per side, then add butter and baste. Check temp.
• Move steaks to a warm plate to rest. Keep the pan on medium.
• Add shrimp to the same pan with a bit more butter. Cook 1 to 2 minutes per side.
• Remove shrimp. Lower heat and build the garlic cream sauce in the same pan.
• Slice the steak against the grain. Plate steak and shrimp, spoon sauce over the top.

Mastering the Sear: Tips for High-Heat Pan Searing and Doneness

Get your pan ripping hot before the steak goes in. When you add the steak, press gently to ensure full contact. Don’t flip early. You want a deep brown crust before turning. When butter foams, tilt the pan and spoon it over the steak for extra flavor. A little thyme or rosemary in the butter is amazing.

Use a meat thermometer so you’re not guessing. Pull the steak a few degrees below your target because carryover heat will finish the job as it rests. Resting keeps those juices inside where they belong.

Timing the Meal: How to Serve Hot Steak and Shrimp Together

The trick is cooking in stages. Start with steak, then shrimp, then sauce. Rested steak stays warm while you make the sauce and sear the shrimp. Everything hits the plate hot and happy. If you’re cooking lobster instead of shrimp, bake the lobster tails while the steak rests and finish with a quick broil for color. It all lines up smoothly, which is why this Delicious Surf and Turf with Creamy Garlic Sauce Recipe works for weeknights and celebrations.

Recipe Variations: From Keto-Friendly to Surf and Turf Pasta

Keto style: swap the Parmesan for a little extra butter and serve with roasted broccoli or asparagus. Low-carb and satisfying. Pasta night: toss fettuccine with a ladle of garlic cream sauce, then top with sliced steak and shrimp. Cajun twist: season shrimp with Cajun spice and squeeze extra lemon into the sauce. Surf and Turf salad: pile arugula with cherry tomatoes, shaved Parmesan, steak slices, and shrimp, then drizzle with a touch of the sauce like a warm dressing.

Best Side Dishes for Surf and Turf: Mashed Potatoes, Asparagus, and More

You cannot go wrong with buttery mashed potatoes, seared asparagus, or roasted carrots. If you want something creamy and cozy, try creamy scalloped potatoes. Feeling sweet and savory? These candied sweet potatoes are a crowd-pleaser with steak. A crisp salad with lemon vinaigrette brightens up the richness, and garlic bread is always a yes for scooping up extra sauce. If you’re stocking your menu, peek at more appetizer and side ideas that play nicely with steak and seafood.

Wine Pairing Guide: The Best Reds and Whites for Steak and Seafood

Avoid clashes

For reds, pick a medium-bodied option that won’t bulldoze the seafood. Pinot Noir and Merlot both work well. If you’re leaning heavy on steak, a Cabernet Sauvignon is classic. For whites, Chardonnay with a touch of oak complements the creamy sauce, while Sauvignon Blanc adds zippy contrast. Sparkling wine is a secret weapon here. It cleans the palate between rich bites.

Make-Ahead Tips, Storage, and Reheating for Optimal Freshness

You can salt your steaks a few hours ahead and keep them uncovered in the fridge. This dry brines the surface and helps build a better crust. Shrimp can be peeled and seasoned in advance, then kept cold until cooking. The garlic cream sauce can be made earlier in the day and reheated gently on low. Add a splash of cream if it tightens up.

Leftovers keep for 2 to 3 days in the fridge. Reheat steak in a low oven and finish in a hot skillet for 30 seconds to re-crisp the edges. Warm shrimp in a low skillet with a little butter, just until heated through. The sauce likes a gentle reheat with a whisk to bring it back to life.

Common Mistakes to Avoid for a Five-Star Home Dining Experience

Don’t crowd the pan. If your steaks are touching or the shrimp are piled up, they’ll steam instead of sear. Dry your proteins first for best browning. Don’t cook straight from the fridge or you’ll get uneven doneness. Taste the sauce and adjust salt, lemon, and pepper at the end. And don’t skip resting your steak. Those few minutes make a big difference.

Internal Temperature Guide: How to Hit Rare, Medium-Rare, and Medium Every Time

Use an instant-read thermometer to keep things simple. For rare, pull the steak at 120 to 125 F. For medium-rare, pull at 130 to 135 F. For medium, pull at 140 to 145 F. Carryover heat will add about 5 degrees as it rests. Shrimp are done when they turn opaque and curl into a gentle C shape. If they curl tight like an O, they’re overcooked. Keep it quick and watch closely.

Common Questions

Can I swap shrimp for scallops?
Yes. Pat scallops very dry, sear in butter and oil until golden, about 2 minutes per side, then finish in the sauce if desired.

What skillet works best?
Cast iron is king for searing. Stainless steel works too, just preheat well and use enough oil to keep things from sticking.

Can I grill the steak?
Absolutely. Sear over high heat, move to indirect heat to finish, and baste with butter at the end. Make the sauce on the stove while the steak rests.

How do I keep the sauce from breaking?
Low heat, slow cheese melting, and a squeeze of lemon at the end. If it gets too thick, whisk in a splash of cream or stock.

Is this dish kid-friendly?
Yes. Keep the pepper light and serve sauce on the side. Kids usually love buttery shrimp and steak.

One Last Nudge to Cook This Tonight

You’ve got everything you need to pull off a restaurant-level dinner without the stress. This Delicious Surf and Turf with Creamy Garlic Sauce Recipe gives you that beautiful sear, juicy shrimp, and a sauce that ties it together. If you want another perspective on flavors and technique, check out this helpful take on Surf and Turf with Garlic Cream Sauce – Ang Sarap. Pick a side or two, cue up good music, and enjoy. When you plate this, I promise it will feel like a small celebration at your table.

Print