Christmas Sugar Cookie Cheesecake Recipe

Sugar Cookie Cheesecake sounds pretty dreamy, right? Picture this: you crave something festive but can’t decide between cookies or cheesecake. Yeah, I’ve been there, stuck at the dessert crossroads. Trust me, if Christmas is coming up in your house, you’ll want a recipe that wows a crowd and still feels sort of nostalgic. I got totally inspired after making these pumpkin sugar cookies and even my famous crumbl chocolate chip cookies – but then I thought, why not go bigger? Bring on that creamy, sugar-cookie magic for the holidays.

Why This Sugar Cookie Cheesecake Is a Must-Try

First things first, this isn’t your everyday cheesecake. It’s like holiday cheer baked right into every slice. The sugar cookie crust is the real kicker – it’s soft but holds up to all that creamy filling. The first time I made one for a friends’ get-together, people legit fought over the last piece. Plus, you don’t need wild baking skills. If you can stir and press dough, you’re in. It’s dreamy, rich, way more fun than plain ol’ cheesecake, and absolutely screams “Christmas!” So if you want something that feels like a treat from a five-star restaurant without stressing out, this is the one.

Print

Ingredients for the Best Sugar Cookie Cheesecake

Okay, so here’s what you’ll need for a truly awesome sugar cookie cheesecake that won’t disappoint:

For the crust:

• One package sugar cookie dough (the tube stuff works, or homemade)
• A sprinkle of flour (helps it not stick)

For the cheesecake filling:

• 3 blocks of cream cheese, softened up
• 1 cup sugar
• 3 eggs (room temp!)
• 1/2 cup sour cream (adds magic creaminess)
• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract

Extras (optional but totally worth it):

• Sprinkles (for the right holiday vibes)
• Whipped cream (seriously, don’t skip)
• White chocolate chips (why not)

If you want more flavor twist ideas, check out the matcha cheesecake recipe I’ve tried before – it’s a whole other vibe.

Toppings & Optional Add-Ins (Sprinkles, Whipped Cream, Ganache)

Here’s the fun part. You literally can’t mess this up. My favorites:
Sprinkles. Just toss them on before or after baking, doesn’t matter. If you’re over-the-top (who isn’t at Christmas?), a pile of whipped cream looks gorgeous. Sometimes I melt a handful of white chocolate chips with a splash of cream for a quick ganache that I drizzle over the top. Kids love it, adults pretend they don’t but go back for seconds. Want to go wild? Crushed up Halloween cookie bark for extra crunch. Get creative.

How to Make Sugar Cookie Cheesecake Step-by-Step

Let’s keep it simple. First, preheat your oven to 325 degrees. While that’s heating up, grab your sugar cookie dough. Press it into the bottom of a springform pan, making a sort of “crust wall” up the sides about an inch. Bake that for 10 minutes, just enough to set the shape.
Beat up your cream cheese and sugar till smooth (lumpy cheesecake, no thanks), then mix in eggs, one by one, finishing with sour cream and vanilla. Pour the filling over your crust. Bake for 50–60 minutes, or until the edges look set but the middle still jiggles a little. Chill it for at least 4 hours. Overnight is even better. Done.

Tips for a Perfect Sugar Cookie Crust

Sugar cookie crust loves to stick and fall apart if you aren’t careful. So, here’s my advice: Don’t skip chilling your dough before pressing it into the pan. It gets less sticky. Flour your hands if you’re working with premade dough. That “inch up the side” thing is key – it keeps the filling inside. Let it cool completely before you add your filling to avoid a soggy base. Oh, and don’t go too thin, or you’ll wind up with cookie shards instead of a proper crust. Happy medium is what you want.

Expert Baking Tips for Crack-Free Cheesecake Every Time

If I had a dollar for every time my cheesecake cracked in my twenties, I’d…well, I’d buy a fancier mixer. Anyway, here’s the scoop:
Room temp ingredients – don’t rush it. That alone solves half your problems. Bake slow and gentle. No slamming the oven door. A water bath helps too, but honestly, just slip a pan of hot water on the rack below. Don’t stress if it does crack. Hide it with whipped cream. Nobody’s judging on Christmas.

Christmas Sugar Cookie Cheesecake with Sprinkles

Here’s where you get to feel like a kid again. Grab red and green sprinkles, douse the top before or after chilling (I like both, just for chaos). Sprinkles in the batter look awesome too, kind of funfetti style. Sometimes I put mini candy canes on top for that over-the-top vibe. Honestly, folks eat with their eyes first, so make it sparkle.

How to Tell When Your Cheesecake Is Done Baking

Okay, this bit is crucial – don’t overbake! The edge should look firm, the middle should still have a little “wiggle.” That’s what the pros say. IF it’s totally solid all through, it’s overdone (cue the heartbreak). Chill, it’ll set up as it cools.

Decorating Ideas for Holidays & Special Occasions

Listen, you don’t have to be an Instagram superstar for this part. Pile on Christmas candies, pipe on snowy whipped cream, scatter colored sugar, or—if you’re extra like me—use edible glitter. Swap colors for other holidays too. Check out my spooky pumpkin cookies if you want Halloween vibes with your cheesecake.

How to Slice & Serve Clean Cheesecake Slices

Straight up: Warm your knife in hot water, wipe it between each cut. I know it sounds extra, but it matters. Don’t take the cheesecake out of the fridge until right before you serve it or you’ll have a gooey mess. I use a thin spatula to lift each slice. Sometimes I even lay out parchment under the whole cheesecake for easier slicing. Works like a charm.

Storage & Freezing Guide (Keep It Fresh Longer)

Stick any leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge. This Christmas sugar cookie cheesecake keeps for around five days. Want it to last longer? Wrap tightly then freeze individual slices for up to two months. Thaw in the fridge overnight, not on the counter. Don’t freeze anything with whipped cream or sprinkles already on – add those after thawing.

What to Serve with Sugar Cookie Cheesecake

Here’s what I’ve paired with this bad boy for extra holiday cheer:

• Glass of cold milk (so simple but unbeatable)
• Steaming mug of coffee or cocoa
• Fresh berries (especially tart ones like raspberries)
• Side of maple brown sugar glazed carrots – yes, veggies go great with dessert!
• Bonus: Crumbled sugar cookies sprinkled over each slice

Why Did My Sugar Cookie Cheesecake Crack?

Man, it happens to the best of us. Usually it’s from overbaking or too-fast cooling. If your kitchen is freezing and you open the oven and just yank it out, boom – crack city. Always let it cool gradually, and don’t stress about cracks. They’re just “character.”

Why Is My Crust Too Soft or Too Hard?

If it’s mushy, the dough probably wasn’t baked long enough before adding filling, or you used a super thick layer. For crusts like concrete, it usually means it’s too thin or you baked it too long up front. Solution? Next time, adjust bake time and check your crust thickness. Easy fix.

Common Questions

The Real Christmas Showstopper: Give It a Whirl!

Honestly, this Christmas sugar cookie cheesecake is a game-changer for holiday tables. It’s got that crowd-friendly comfort, a little bit playful, and totally doable even if you don’t bake every week. If you liked this recipe, exploring other creative desserts from First Step Recipes can spark even more baking magic at home. Just try it once – your family might beg for a repeat every year, like mine.