Pumpkin Spice Cookies Recipe

Pumpkin Spice Cookies always remind me of that hungry, impatient feeling you get right when fall rolls in. You know what I mean? The air gets crisp, you want something cozy, but…wait, not soup again. You want something with real fall flavor. But who has time for finicky desserts? I used to grab the first recipe online and, let’s just say sometimes they turned out more like pumpkin pancakes than cookies.

If you need the kind you can dunk in a glass of milk (or just inhale twelve in a sitting), you’re in the right place. And by the way, if you’re also into all things pumpkin, you’ll love these pumpkin chocolate chip cookies or a slice of spiced pumpkin loaf cake on the side.

Chewy Pumpkin Cookies: The Best Fall Recipe

Let’s get right down to it. I think a pumpkin spice cookie should be chewy, with just a little crisp at the edge. None of this cakey business. If you’ve had the fluffy kind (they’re fine, I guess), just know these are different. I actually went through at least eight batches before I managed that perfect bite, not bragging, just dedicated (or maybe stubborn). The combination of pumpkin spice with brown sugar and the perfect oven temp, that’s where the magic happens. So, let’s talk about making chewy pumpkin cookies that’ll have people following their nose into your kitchen.

Print

Key Ingredients That Make the Perfect Texture

There isn’t one single ingredient that makes or breaks these cookies, but some matter more than others. Brown sugar? A must, trust me. It gives a caramel-like chew that plain white sugar misses. Butter? Oh, for sure, but skip melted, go with softened (nobody wants puddles). And here’s where I get picky: Pumpkin purée, but not too wet, or else your dough ends up sticky and spread too much. A pinch of salt makes all the flavors brighter, and of course, a healthy dose of pumpkin spice. Don’t even think about skipping the vanilla, by the way. Sometimes the simplest things make the biggest difference.

Ingredients for Chewy Pumpkin Cookies

• 1 cup brown sugar (light or dark, but I use dark for richer flavor)
• ½ cup white sugar
• ½ cup unsalted butter, softened
• ⅓ cup pumpkin purée (blotted, more on that in a second)
• 1 egg yolk (yep, just the yolk)
• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
• 1 ¾ cups all-purpose flour
• ½ teaspoon baking soda
• ¼ teaspoon salt
• 1 tablespoon pumpkin spice

Pumpkin Purée: Fresh vs. Canned (and Why Blotting Matters)

So, about the pumpkin. I’m all for fresh, I mean, who doesn’t love a DIY moment, right? But honestly, canned pumpkin works better here. It’s more predictable, especially for cookies. The only trick? Blot it! Spread your pumpkin purée on some paper towels, press out as much water as you can. Too much moisture means puffy, cakey cookies instead of that bendy, chewy bite. Homemade pumpkin can work too, but it’s often even wetter. Always, always blot.

How to Make Chewy Pumpkin Cookies Step by Step

First…don’t panic. Cookies aren’t fussy if you slow down for five minutes. Start by creaming the butter with both sugars until light and fluffy. Bring in the egg yolk, vanilla, and blotted pumpkin. Mix until just combined. Next comes dry ingredients. Whisk together flour, baking soda, salt, and all that glorious pumpkin spice. Gently blend the wet and dry, go easy or you’ll get tough cookies. Refrigerate the dough for 30 minutes. Scoop onto a baking sheet lined with parchment, leaving space. Bake as directed. Easy, right?

Baking Time and Temperature for Perfect Chewy Cookies

Here’s where things get wonky if you’re not careful. Bake at 350°F. Set your timer for 9 minutes, then check. They should look just set at the edges and a little soft in the center. Don’t overbake. If you want soft and chewy, leave those middles a touch underdone. Cookies keep cooking on the sheet for a few minutes after you pull them out, so let them chill before moving to a rack.

Expert Tips for Soft and Chewy Pumpkin Cookies

Okay, real talk. Wanna level-up these cookies? Don’t skip that dough chill. Letting the dough rest in the fridge for even 30 minutes lets everything relax, the flavors meld, and keeps your cookies from going flat. If you’re feeling wild, try browning the butter first (let it cool before mixing in). Use the freshest pumpkin spice blend you can find, seriously, it’s worth it. Oh, and measuring flour by weight changes everything, but if you don’t have a scale, just fluff and spoon it into your cups.

Tricks to Enhance Chewiness

Too many fluffy pumpkin cookies out there, so let’s talk chew. Use only the egg yolk, not the whole egg. Yolks give richness and chew, while the white is just moisture (makes things cakey). Take time to blot your pumpkin. Don’t skip the brown sugar, use more of it than white. And always underbake, just a little. If you want that satisfying bend instead of a crumbly mess, these tiny changes matter.

Adjusting Bake Time for Crisp Edges and Soft Centers

If you’re after those bakery-style edges (who isn’t), play with bake time. For a crisp rim, let them sit in the oven 1-2 minutes longer, until just browned. For an even softer center, shave off a minute but don’t touch them right away, let ‘em cool on the pan. Every oven’s different, honestly, so it helps to bake a test cookie first.

Flavor Variations and Add-Ins

Honestly, you can take pumpkin spice cookies just about anywhere. Toss in chocolate chips, white chocolate chunks, or swap in dried cranberries for a little tart burst. Chopped pecans are great too. Feeling extra? Roll the dough balls in cinnamon sugar before baking for that café finish. If you want to branch out more, my apple pumpkin streusel muffins have a cozy, fruity twist, or there’s something totally wild like pumpkin cinnamon rolls with cream cheese waiting for you too.

Serving Suggestions for Pumpkin Cookies

• Warm, right out of the oven, is the way to go (seriously, they’re amazing with coffee).
• Dunked in cold milk if you’re a classic type.
• Sandwiched with a little cream cheese frosting for a fancy treat.
• Crumbled on top of vanilla ice cream for dessert with zero effort.

How to Store and Freeze Pumpkin Cookies

Here’s a little trick: Stash your cooled cookies in an airtight container, and they’ll stay chewy for about 3 days. If you really want to keep them long-term, freeze in a zip-top bag, just thaw at room temp (or eat straight from the freezer, no judgment). Dough freezes too. Roll into balls, freeze on a tray, then bag ‘em for baking on demand.

Common Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Been there, fixed that. If your cookies are too cakey, you probably left too much moisture in your pumpkin or used the full egg. Too flat and greasy? Butter was too soft or you skipped chilling the dough. Dough won’t hold its shape? Add a spoonful of flour at a time. Overbaked? Don’t stress, just warm ‘em for ten seconds in the microwave, they’ll soften right up.

Nutrition and Dietary Modifications

Okay, so full transparency, these are cookies. But you can lighten things up, use half whole wheat flour, swap in coconut oil for some of the butter, or sub in coconut sugar for a different twist. Want less sugar? Drop it down by 1/4 cup. If you’re after protein, hey…try pumpkin protein balls for a totally different healthy snack.

Gluten-Free Pumpkin Cookie Adaptations

Need to go gluten-free? Easy. Use a good 1:1 gluten-free flour blend (not just almond flour or they’ll crumble). Add a little extra chill time for the dough, since gluten-free tends to be looser. The flavor is honestly just as good, promise. Test a single cookie first just in case the texture throws you.

Best Occasions to Make Chewy Pumpkin Cookies

Not to be dramatic but I think every day is cookie day, especially in fall. Still, these are perfect for holiday cookie trays, cozy weekend baking sessions, friendsgiving, or bagged up as cute little gifts for your neighbors. (Honestly, I’d take these over fudge at Christmas any year.)

Make-Ahead and Gifting Ideas

Wanna be a cookie hero? Make your dough ahead, freeze it, then bake right before serving. Or, scoop ‘em right after mixing and freeze balls for quick treats. For gifting, toss cooled cookies into a cellophane bag with a cute ribbon. Homemade always tastes better, especially when you share it.

Pumpkin Spice Cookies Common Questions

Why You’ll Want to Bake These on Repeat

Alright, so if fall had a flavor, for me it’d basically be pumpkin spice cookies baked just right. Soft, chewy, nostalgic, a little messy but totally worth it. Anyone who loves spiced bakes needs this in their back pocket. And if you’re looking for even more inspiration, check out trusted baking ideas on our Pinterest for perfect cookies. Give them a go and let me know how many disappear before they’ve even cooled off. Don’t blame me if they vanish!