Ham and Havarti Cheese Sliders: Easy Cheesy Party & Game Day Favorite

Sun hits the counter in a certain way. The glossy tops of the rolls light up and I decide to make something simple and warm. I liked the sharp yellow of the cheese against the soft, shiny bread. The ham brings a salty ribbon through each bite. It felt like a small, bright thing to bring to a table.

Most days I want food that looks like it moved. These do. They puff, they brown, they melt. And yes, the poppy seeds matter they give the top texture and a tiny crunch.

If you like easy weeknight things with a cozy feel, you’ll get it. I also keep simple soups on rotation; this one pairs well with a bowl of creamy chicken mac and cheese soup when the evening wants more than bread.

How the Recipe Unfolds

It’s honest and fast. Nothing fussy. The idea: assemble, brush with a buttery poppy seed glaze, hide it under foil so the cheese melts, then pull the foil back so the tops toast.

You’ll make a quick butter-mustard mixture. Spread it on. Bake. The smell will pull people into the kitchen. I learned this the hard way, don’t let them peek too early.

If you want a bit of sweetness next to the salty ham, add a small side of pickled cucumbers or a simple slaw. A tangy counterpoint keeps everything lively. And if you like playful pasta with dinner, try a simple spaghetti-and-cheese on the side for kids who want pasta and bread.

Ingredients to Have Ready

1 package Savory Butter Hawaiian Rolls (12 count), 12 slices black forest ham, 6 slices Havarti cheese, 4 tbsp salted butter, 1 tsp Dijon mustard, 1/4 tsp Worcestershire sauce (optional), 1/4 tsp onion powder (optional), 1 tbsp poppy seeds, Add All Ingredients to Your Walmart Cart (Adds everything with one click! You can edit items before you check out.)

I like to pull everything out first. Lay the ham flat so it’s easy to layer. Stack the cheese and slice it in half if your slices are large. Small moves save time.

If you want a soup on the side, consider this classic ham and bean soup, it’s simple and uses similar pantry notes.

Bringing this together with easy steps

• Prepare rolls and baking dish. Slice the entire block of rolls in half without separating the rolls.
• Remove top half of Hawaiian rolls and set aside. Place bottom half of rolls in a 9×12 baking pan, lightly greased with butter., Add ham and cheese.
• Layer each roll with a slice of ham and a half slice of cheese., Prepare and add buttery topping. In a microwavable bowl, cover and heat butter for about 30 second or until melted.
• Stir in Dijon mustard, Worcestershire sauce, onion powder and poppy seeds.Add the top layer of rolls and brush with butter-poppy seed mixture., Bake.
• Loosely cover with foil and bake at 350˚ for about 15 minutes. Remove foil and bake an additional 5 minutes or until cheese is melted and tops of buns are golden brown.

Follow those steps. They work. Don’t rush the last five minutes, that’s when the tops go glossy and a little crisp.

If you end up with extra butter mixture, brush a little on the edges of the pan for a browned, buttery crust. That bit gets eaten first in my house.

Serving Ideas That Feel Natural and Flexible

Serve warm, straight from the pan. Tear one apart and let the cheese stretch. People will smile.

Make simple sides: a green salad with lemon vinaigrette, crunchy carrot sticks, or pickles. For a fuller meal, stack two sliders with a small bowl of soup. Leftover ham can move into a quick Instant Pot ham, cheese & broccoli soup the next day no drama.

If you’re serving a crowd, put the pan in the middle of the table and a pair of tongs beside it. Let everyone grab what they want. It keeps things casual.

Keeping Leftovers for Later

Cool the pan slightly, then cover tightly with foil or plastic wrap. Store in the fridge for up to 3 days. Reheat gently in a 350°F oven for about 8–10 minutes so the cheese warms without drying the rolls. Or microwave a single slider for 20–30 seconds if you’re in a hurry. It won’t be as crisp, but it will be comforting.

Freeze individual sliders wrapped in foil for up to a month. Thaw overnight in the fridge and reheat in the oven. I prefer the oven method because it brings back some of the top’s texture.

Small Details That Matter and Tips That Help

Use real butter. It browns better and smells like the kitchen is doing something important.

Slice the rolls while they’re still together. It makes keeping the halves even so much easier. This also keeps assembly tidy.

If your Havarti slices feel thick, cut them in half. You want even melting, not a cheese mountain. And if your ham is very salty, skip the Worcestershire; the sandwich will still sing.

Poppy seeds look small but they change the mood of the top. They add a whisper of crunch and a little visual drama.

Prep Tips That Help

Arrange everything on the counter before you start. Rolls on one side, ham next, cheese in front, butter in a small microwave-safe bowl. Clean as you go. It speeds things up.

If you have helpers, give one person the job of brushing the butter mixture while another layers ham. Little tasks make this almost meditative instead of chaotic.

Heat the oven while you assemble. By the time you brush the top, it’s ready to go in.

Easy Variations You Can Try

Swap the ham for turkey. Same method, different mood.

Use swiss instead of Havarti for a sharper, nuttier flavor. Or mix a slice of Havarti and a slice of sharp cheddar for more bite.

Add a smear of honey mustard to the bottom roll if you like a touch of sweet. It plays nicely with the buttery top.

Add thin apple slices for a sweet-crisp note. It sounds odd, but it’s good. Try it once.

Choosing the Right Pan or Dish

A 9×12 glass or metal pan works well. Glass gives a gentler brown; metal makes the bottoms crispier. I reach for glass when I want the tops to shine without risking burned edges.

If you want deeper sliders, use an 8×8 pan and expect thicker layers. They’ll take a few extra minutes to heat through.

Color matters. A lighter pan shows golden color better. Dark pans can hide how done the top looks. So if you like to judge by sight, pick light glass or ceramic.

Questions That Come Up

Will these be too greasy?
Not if you measure the butter. Four tablespoons gives you a glossy top without drowning the rolls. If you’re worried, brush lightly.

Can I make these ahead?
Yes. Assemble them, cover, and refrigerate for a few hours. Bake when you’re ready. If you preheat the oven, add a couple extra minutes.

What cheese melts best?
Havarti melts beautifully because it gets soft and creamy. If you don’t have it, swiss or young cheddar works fine.

Can I use leftover dinner ham?
Absolutely. Leftover ham makes these feel even more like a cozy, thrifty meal.

Do the poppy seeds matter?
They’re small, but they add texture and a finished look. Skip them if you must, but I don’t.

A Thought Before You Go

This is one of those meals that looks like you planned, even if you didn’t. The shine on the rolls, the cheese that pulls, those little things make people pause. It’s quick, kind, and small-ceremony cozy. That’s why I come back to it.

If you want the original inspiration or a similar classic take, check the recipe that started this vibe at Ham and Havarti Cheese Sliders – Mighty Mrs.

Print