Deliciously Fun Easter Poke Cake You’ll Want to Try!

Easter Poke Cake is my go to fix when I want something cute and colorful for spring, but I do not want to stress about fancy layers or perfect piping. You know that feeling when you need a dessert that looks like you tried really hard, even if you did not? This is that cake. It is soft, chilled, creamy, and every bite has those little pockets of pudding that make people go back for seconds. I started making it for family Easter brunch, and now it is basically requested every year. If you have kids around, they will hover by the fridge like it is a science project waiting to happen.

Ingredient Substitutions and Swaps (Homemade Cake, Dairy-Free, Sugar-Free Options)

The classic version uses a boxed white or vanilla cake, instant pudding, milk, and whipped topping. But you can absolutely swap things based on what you have or what you need.

If you want to go homemade, use your favorite vanilla sheet cake recipe and bake it in a 9×13 pan. Honestly, I still use a box sometimes because it is quick and it tastes nostalgic.

Easy swaps that work well:

• Homemade cake: any vanilla or yellow cake baked in a 9×13 pan
• Dairy-free: use almond milk or oat milk for the pudding, and a dairy-free whipped topping
• Sugar-free: sugar-free cake mix and sugar-free instant pudding (the texture stays surprisingly good)
• Whipped topping alternative: homemade whipped cream with a little powdered sugar and vanilla

If you are feeling like branching out from vanilla desserts this season, you might also like something creamy like this sugar cookie cheesecake for another fun holiday table option.

Essential Tools and Equipment for a Perfect Poke Cake

You do not need much, which is part of why I love this recipe. The main thing is making sure you can poke holes evenly so the pudding actually gets down into the cake.

Here is what I always grab:

9×13 baking pan (glass or metal both work)
Wooden spoon handle or a thick straw for the holes
Mixing bowl and whisk for pudding
Spatula for spreading topping
Food coloring in pastel shades (gel is my favorite because it does not water things down)

That is it. No special tips, no weird tools, no gadgets you will use once and regret buying.

How to Make Easter Poke Cake Step-by-Step (Bake, Poke, Fill, Chill, Frost)

This is the part where it feels almost too easy for how cute the final cake looks. I will walk you through exactly how I do it.

Step 1: Bake

Bake your vanilla or white cake in a 9×13 pan according to the recipe or box directions. Let it cool for about 15 to 20 minutes. You want it warm, not hot, because warm cake soaks up pudding better.

Step 2: Poke

Use the handle of a wooden spoon to poke holes all over the cake. Space them about an inch apart. Push almost to the bottom, but try not to tear the cake up too much.

Step 3: Fill

Whisk instant vanilla pudding mix with cold milk until it thickens, usually about 2 minutes. Then pour it over the cake, aiming so it goes into the holes. I use a spoon to nudge pudding into spots that look dry.

Step 4: Chill

Cover and refrigerate. This is where the magic happens. The pudding sets up inside the cake, and the whole thing turns into that soft, creamy texture people love in Easter Poke Cake.

Step 5: Frost

Spread whipped topping over the top once the pudding layer is set. Then decorate with pastel sprinkles, candies, or whatever makes you happy.

Little side note: if you love light and fluffy desserts, you would probably enjoy this Japanese cheesecake too. Totally different vibe, but same crowd pleasing energy.

Pro Tips for a Moist and Flavorful Poke Cake Every Time*

I have made this enough times to learn what actually matters and what is just extra fuss.

My best tips:

Do not overbake the cake. If it is dry to start with, it will never be as good. Pull it when a toothpick comes out with a few moist crumbs.
Poke while warm. Warm cake welcomes the pudding.
Mix pudding until just thickened. If you wait too long, it gets too set in the bowl and will not flow into the holes.
Chill long enough. This is the difference between good and wow.

How to Get Perfect Pastel Colors and Easter-Themed Decoration Ideas

Pastels are the whole reason this cake looks like spring. I usually do one of two things: pastel swirls on top, or pastel drizzle lines.

For pastel swirls, divide whipped topping into 3 to 4 bowls. Add a tiny bit of gel food coloring to each. Then spoon random dollops onto the cake and lightly swirl with a butter knife. Do not overmix or it turns muddy.

Decoration ideas that are easy but adorable:

Mini eggs around the border
Bunny sprinkles in the center
Shredded coconut tinted green for a grass look
Marshmallow bunnies or chicks for a playful vibe

Flavor Variations and Creative Easter Poke Cake Ideas (Chocolate, Strawberry, Lemon, Jello)

Once you get the base version down, it is hard not to start playing with flavors. Easter Poke Cake is basically a blank canvas.

Some variations I actually make and love:

Chocolate: use chocolate cake, chocolate pudding, and top with chocolate shavings.
Strawberry: use white cake, strawberry pudding, and add sliced strawberries on top right before serving.
Lemon: use lemon cake mix, lemon pudding, and add a little lemon zest into the whipped topping.
Jello: swap pudding for Jello, pour it in while liquid, then chill until set. It is brighter and more retro.

If you want another dessert with a bold, fun color for a party table, these bloody red velvet cake pops are a cute option for themed gatherings too.

Make-Ahead, Storage, and Freezing Tips for Easter Poke Cake

This is one of the best make ahead desserts I know, which is a lifesaver on busy holidays.

Make ahead: You can make it 1 to 2 days early. In fact, I think it tastes better the next day.
Storage: Keep it covered in the fridge. It stays good for about 4 days, though the toppings look freshest in the first 2 days.
Freezing: You can freeze the cake, but I prefer freezing it before adding whipped topping. Wrap well, freeze up to 1 month, thaw in the fridge, then top and decorate.

How Long to Chill a Poke Cake for Best Texture and Flavor

I know chilling is the annoying part because you want to dig in, but it is also the whole point.

My rule is at least 4 hours, but overnight is even better. If you cut it too early, the pudding will not be fully set inside the holes and slices can look messy. It will still taste good, but it will not have that perfect chilled bite that makes Easter Poke Cake feel extra special.

Serving Suggestions for Easter Brunch, Parties, and Spring Gatherings

I love serving this cold straight from the fridge. It is refreshing, especially when the rest of the meal is warm.

• Easter brunch: serve with coffee, fruit salad, and something savory like quiche
• Kid parties: cut into smaller squares and add extra sprinkles on each piece
• Potlucks: bring it in the same pan you baked it in, less stress
• Spring dinners: serve with berries on the side for a fresh pop

If you are the kind of person who likes a cozy cake moment with coffee, save this pumpkin coffee cake recipe for later in the year. Not Easter themed, but so good for gatherings.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Making a Pudding Poke Cake

I have made every mistake so you do not have to.

Not poking enough holes: the pudding cannot spread evenly, so some bites are plain cake.
Letting the cake cool completely before poking: it still works, but the pudding does not soak in as nicely.
Using warm milk for pudding: it will not set right. Cold milk only.
Rushing the chill time: the slices fall apart and the texture is not as creamy.
Overmixing pastel colors: you lose the pretty look and it turns into one dull color.

How to Transport and Present Your Easter Poke Cake Beautifully

If you are taking this to someone else’s house, a little planning helps. Since it is chilled and topped with whipped goodness, it needs to stay cold.

What I do:

Use a lid if your 9×13 has one, or cover tightly with plastic wrap and then foil so it does not touch the topping.
Keep it cold in a cooler bag with an ice pack underneath the pan.
Decorate at the destination if you are using fragile candies or detailed sprinkles. I bring a little bag of toppings and do the final look in two minutes on the counter.

 

I like to think of this as the quick guide section you can come back to when you are in the middle of baking and your kitchen is already a mess. Easter Poke Cake is basically: bake the cake, poke holes, pour pudding, chill, then top and decorate. Keep the milk cold, do not rush the fridge time, and you will be golden. If you are making it ahead, wait to add delicate toppings until closer to serving so everything looks fresh and colorful.

Common Questions

Can I use any cake mix flavor?
Yes. White, vanilla, lemon, strawberry, and even chocolate work great. Just match the pudding flavor so it makes sense.

Do I have to use whipped topping?
Nope. Homemade whipped cream works fine. Just keep it chilled and do not add it until the cake is fully cold.

Why is my pudding not going into the holes?
Usually the pudding got too thick before you poured it. Mix it, wait about a minute, then pour right away while it is still loose enough to flow.

Can I make Easter Poke Cake the night before?
Yes, and I recommend it. Overnight chilling makes the texture better and the slices cleaner.

How do I keep the pastel colors from looking weird?
Use gel coloring and only a tiny bit. Swirl gently. If you mix too much, you lose the soft pastel look.

A Sweet, Simple Easter Win

If you need a dessert that looks festive without turning your day into a baking marathon, Easter Poke Cake is the answer. It is easy, forgiving, and it feeds a crowd without drama. Chill it long enough, keep the colors soft, and have fun with the toppings. And if you want to compare versions, this Easter Poke Cake – OMG Chocolate Desserts post is another great take to peek at before you pick your own twist. Now go make it, clear a spot in the fridge, and get ready for the compliments.

Print