High Protein Cottage Cheese Mushroom Soup Recipe

Cottage Cheese Mushroom Soup Recipe is my answer to those nights when I want something cozy but I do not want to babysit a complicated pot of food. You know the feeling, you are hungry, you want dinner to taste like a hug, and you also want it to actually keep you full. This soup does that for me because it is creamy without being heavy, and it has a nice protein boost thanks to cottage cheese. The mushroom flavor is deep and savory, and the texture ends up silky if you follow a couple of simple steps. If you have ever had a creamy mushroom soup that felt a little flat, this one fixes that in a very weeknight friendly way.

Essential Ingredients for the Ultimate Nutritious Mushroom Soup

Let me keep this practical. The best bowls of Cottage Cheese Mushroom Soup Recipe come down to a few smart ingredients and one good habit, which is tasting as you go. Here is what I grab most of the time, and you can tweak from there.

• Mushrooms (I like a mix for more flavor)
• Cottage cheese (blended smooth)
• Bone broth (chicken or beef)
• Shallots or onion
• Garlic
• Fresh thyme or dried thyme
• Butter or olive oil
• Salt and black pepper
• Optional, a splash of lemon juice for balance

If you are in a big soup mood lately, you might also like my cozy bowl of chicken mushroom soup for another weeknight friendly option.

Selecting the Best Mushrooms: Cremini, Shiitake, and Portobello Mix

Mushrooms are the main event here, so it is worth choosing a combo that tastes like something. Cremini brings that classic earthy flavor, shiitake brings a slightly smoky depth, and portobello makes everything feel meatier. If your store only has one type, do cremini and call it a day. But if you can grab two or three, it really boosts the flavor with zero extra effort.

One small tip I learned the hard way, do not rinse mushrooms under water like you are washing dishes. They soak it up. I usually wipe them with a damp paper towel or give them a quick rinse and pat them very dry right away.

Also, slice some and roughly chop some. The different shapes make the soup feel more interesting when you eat it.

The Protein Core: Choosing the Right Cottage Cheese (Full Fat vs. Low Fat)

Here is where the magic happens. Cottage cheese is what turns this into a high protein creamy soup without needing heavy cream. Full fat cottage cheese gives you a richer taste and the smoothest texture, in my opinion. Low fat works too and it still tastes good, but it can be a tiny bit tangier.

My go to move is blending the cottage cheese until completely smooth before it goes anywhere near the pot. If you have a small blender or food processor, use it. If not, an immersion blender can work, just be patient and blend until it looks like a thick cream.

And if you are a cottage cheese fan, you would probably love this high protein blueberry cottage cheese bake for breakfast meal prep.

Aromatics and Herbs: Fresh Thyme, Garlic, and Shallots

This is the part that makes your kitchen smell amazing. Shallots give a gentle sweetness that plays really well with mushrooms, and garlic adds that warm savory bite. Fresh thyme is my favorite here, but dried thyme is totally fine. If using dried, start smaller because it gets strong fast once it simmers.

I also like black pepper in this soup more than I like it in most soups. The peppery kick wakes up the cottage cheese and keeps the bowl from tasting too mild.

Liquid Gold: The Benefits of Using Chicken or Beef Bone Broth

Bone broth gives this soup a deeper, more satisfying base than plain stock. Chicken bone broth keeps the flavor lighter and more classic. Beef bone broth makes it feel extra hearty, almost like a steakhouse mushroom soup vibe.

Look for a broth you actually like the taste of. If it is overly salty, you will fight it the whole time. I usually buy low sodium and then salt at the end when the flavors are done doing their thing.

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Make Creamy Mushroom Soup with Cottage Cheese

This is the part you are here for. I make this Cottage Cheese Mushroom Soup Recipe in about 35 to 45 minutes, and most of that time is hands off simmering.

1) Sauté the aromatics. In a large pot, melt butter or warm olive oil. Add shallots and cook until soft, then add garlic for about 30 seconds.

2) Cook the mushrooms. Add mushrooms and a pinch of salt. Cook until they release their liquid and start turning golden.

3) Add thyme. Toss it in and stir for a minute so it blooms.

4) Deglaze. Add a splash of broth and scrape the browned bits from the bottom.

5) Simmer. Add the rest of the broth and simmer 10 to 15 minutes.

6) Blend. Blend part or all of the soup until smooth, then stir back any chunks you want to keep.

7) Add blended cottage cheese gently. Lower the heat and stir it in slowly. Warm it through, do not boil.

8) Finish. Taste for salt, pepper, and a squeeze of lemon if you want brightness.

If you are on a soup kick, my chicken mac and cheese soup is another creamy comfort bowl for those colder weeks.

Sautéing and Searing: How to Build Deep Mushroom Flavor

If your mushroom soup has ever tasted kind of bland, it is usually because the mushrooms did not get enough time in the pot. You want them to go from pale and watery to darker, smaller, and a little golden around the edges.

My simple rule is this, do not crowd the pot. If your mushrooms are piled up and steaming, they will not brown well. Cook them in a wide pot, and stir, but not constantly. Let them sit for a minute so they can caramelize a bit.

Deglazing the Pot: Unleashing Savory Depth

Those brown bits stuck to the bottom are flavor. Deglazing sounds fancy, but it is just adding a splash of broth and scraping with a wooden spoon. It takes 20 seconds and makes the soup taste like you worked harder than you did.

The Simmering Secret: Developing the Herb-Infused Base

Once the broth goes in, simmering is where everything comes together. Keep it at a gentle simmer, not a rolling boil. This gives thyme time to flavor the broth and lets the mushrooms share all that savory goodness.

I also taste the broth right before blending. If it tastes a little flat, it might just need a pinch more salt. If it tastes heavy, a tiny splash of lemon wakes it up fast.

Mastering the Blend: Achieving a Silky, Velvet-Smooth Consistency

You have options. If you want a super smooth soup, blend it all. If you want it rustic, blend only half and leave the rest chunky. I usually blend about two thirds because I like some mushroom bites in there.

For safety, if you use a blender, do not fill it to the top with hot soup. Blend in batches and vent the lid a little so steam can escape.

Professional Tips for Working with Blended Cottage Cheese in Soups

Preventing Curdling: The Importance of Tempering and Low Heat

This is the biggest deal with any dairy. Cottage cheese will behave if you treat it gently. Turn the heat to low before adding it. If your soup is super hot, you can temper it by stirring a ladle of hot soup into the blended cottage cheese first, then pour that mixture back into the pot. And once it is in, do not boil. Just warm it until it is steamy and ready.

How to Achieve the Perfect Thickness Without Flour or Cornstarch

The thickness comes from two things, blended mushrooms and blended cottage cheese. If you want it thicker, simmer the blended soup a few extra minutes before adding the cottage cheese. If you want it thinner, add a splash more broth at the end. Simple and no starchy thickeners needed.

Room Temperature vs. Cold Dairy: Why It Matters for Texture

If you remember, let the cottage cheese sit out for 10 to 15 minutes before blending and adding. Cold dairy hitting hot soup can lead to a slightly grainy texture. Not always, but often enough that I now try to take the chill off first.

Flavor Variations and Dietary Adaptations

Keto and Low Carb Adjustments: Keeping Net Carbs Low

This soup is already pretty low carb if you stick to mushrooms, broth, herbs, and cottage cheese. For extra keto friendly vibes, use full fat cottage cheese and top with a little parmesan. Skip croutons and go for pepitas or chopped nuts for crunch.

Vegetarian Options: Substituting Vegetable Bone Broth and Miso

To make it vegetarian, use a rich vegetable broth. If you have miso, add a small spoon at the end for that savory depth. Do not boil after adding miso, just stir it in off heat.

And if you want another comfort soup idea for your rotation, take a peek at this slow cooker broccoli cheese soup for an easy set it and forget it day.

Dairy-Free Swaps: Using Silken Tofu or Cashew Cream

If dairy is not your thing, you can still keep the creamy feel. Blend silken tofu with a little broth and stir it in at low heat. Or use cashew cream if you like that slightly sweet, rich finish. The taste changes, but you still get a smooth and cozy mushroom soup.

Add-In Boosters: Incorporating Shredded Chicken or White Beans for Extra Fiber

If you want to stretch the pot, add shredded chicken or white beans. Chicken makes it extra hearty and keeps the protein high. White beans add fiber and make the soup even thicker after blending a little.

This is also a great way to use leftover rotisserie chicken, especially on those weeks where you are tired of sandwiches.

2026 “Fibermaxxing” Toppings and Serving Suggestions

I keep seeing people talk about fibermaxxing, and honestly, I get it. When you add a couple smart toppings, this Cottage Cheese Mushroom Soup Recipe turns into a full meal that actually keeps you satisfied.

Crunchy Elements: Roasted Pepitas and Sourdough Croutons

Crunch makes creamy soup way more fun to eat. Try roasted pepitas for a nutty bite, or sourdough croutons if you want that classic comfort feel. If you do croutons, toast them well so they stay crisp on top.

Fresh Finishes: Microgreens, Chives, and Truffle Oil Drizzle

Chopped chives are my everyday choice, fresh and mild. Microgreens make it feel fancy with zero effort. And truffle oil is optional, but one tiny drizzle can make the bowl smell like a restaurant. Go easy because it can take over fast.

Pairing Ideas: Best High-Protein Sides for a Complete Meal

If you want a high protein side, I love serving it with something simple and filling. A few ideas:

• Egg salad or a couple hard boiled eggs
• Turkey roll ups with mustard
• A slice of high protein flatbread like this 2 ingredient cottage cheese flatbread

That flatbread is especially good for dipping, which is my favorite way to eat this soup.

Meal Prep, Storage, and Reheating Instructions

This Cottage Cheese Mushroom Soup Recipe is one of my favorite meal prep soups because the flavor gets even better the next day.

How to Store Leftovers for Optimal Freshness (Fridge vs. Freezer)

In the fridge, it keeps well in an airtight container for about 3 to 4 days. For the freezer, it can work, but dairy based soups sometimes change texture a bit. If you plan to freeze it, freeze before adding the cottage cheese, then add the blended cottage cheese when you reheat.

Reheating Without Breaking the Sauce: Stovetop vs. Microwave

Stovetop is the safest. Reheat on low and stir often. Microwave works too, but do it in short bursts and stir between, so it warms evenly. The main thing is do not let it boil hard after the cottage cheese is in.

Batch Cooking Tips for Busy Weeknights

If you are batch cooking, chop mushrooms and aromatics ahead and store them separately. You can also blend the cottage cheese in advance and keep it in the fridge. Then the day you cook, it feels like the soup makes itself.

Nutritional Breakdown: Macros and Micronutrients

I am not a dietitian, but I do like having a general idea of why a meal makes me feel good. This soup is one of those bowls that feels comforting and still checks a lot of nutrition boxes.

Protein Per Serving: Reaching the 20g+ Goal

If you use a decent amount of cottage cheese and a protein rich broth, getting 20g or more per serving is realistic, especially if you add chicken. Exact numbers depend on your brands and portion size, but it is absolutely a solid high protein option.

Essential Minerals: Selenium, Vitamin D, and Potassium

Mushrooms bring selenium, and some varieties can provide vitamin D depending on how they were grown. Broth and dairy can add potassium too. It is not just comfort food, it actually brings some helpful nutrients to the table.

Calorie Count: A Satiating Low-Calorie Comfort Food

Compared to heavy cream based soups, this one can be lighter while still feeling rich. If you go with low fat cottage cheese and keep toppings simple, it stays pretty reasonable calorie wise, while still being filling.

Common Questions

Can I make this soup ahead of time?
Yes, and it tastes even better the next day. Reheat gently on low so the dairy stays smooth.

Do I have to blend the cottage cheese?
I strongly recommend it. Blending is what gives you that creamy texture instead of little curds.

What if my soup turns out too thick?
Just add a bit more broth and stir. It loosens up quickly.

Can I use dried thyme instead of fresh?
Absolutely. Start with a smaller amount, then add more if needed after simmering.

How do I make it taste more savory?
Brown the mushrooms longer, deglaze the pot, and consider a tiny splash of soy sauce or a small spoon of miso at the end.

A Cozy Bowl Worth Repeating

If you try this Cottage Cheese Mushroom Soup Recipe, I think you will be surprised by how creamy it feels without relying on heavy cream. Focus on browning the mushrooms, keeping the heat low when the cottage cheese goes in, and tasting at the end for salt and pepper. And if you want another fun variation, check out this Easy Mushroom Soup Recipe No Cream (High Protein) for more inspiration. Make a pot this week, grab a spoon, and let dinner be the easy part of your day.

Print